The IRS control test
IRS Topic 756 puts it in one line: household workers are your employees if you can control not only the work they do, but also how they do it. For other kinds of work the IRS looks at three areas of the relationship:
- Behavioral control. Do you set the schedule, the routines, the rules for the children, what’s done and in what order?
- Financial control. Do you supply what’s needed for the job? Is the worker paid by the hour or week rather than per project, with no chance of profit or loss?
- The relationship. Is it ongoing? Is caring for your children the core of what you need, rather than a one-off service?
A typical nanny answers yes to nearly all of them.
When the worker isn’t your employee
- An agency employs them. If the agency provides the worker and controls what work is done and how, the worker is the agency’s employee, and the agency handles payroll.
- Care in their own home. Someone who cares for your child in their home (a home daycare) generally isn’t your employee.
- A real independent business. A self-employed worker usually provides their own tools and offers services to the public. The IRS example is a lawn care business that hires and directs its own helpers.
Examples
| Arrangement | Usually |
|---|---|
| Nanny in your home, your schedule and rules | Your employee |
| After-school sitter, 15 hours a week, your home | Your employee |
| Nanny share, care at your home or the other family’s | Each family usually pays and reports its share |
| Licensed home daycare, care at the provider’s home | Not your employee |
| Agency that employs and directs the caregiver | The agency’s employee |
| Placement agency that only found the nanny | Your employee |
Nanny shares can be set up in more than one way; each family usually pays and reports its own part of the wages. If the arrangement is unusual, the IRS can rule on it if you file Form SS-8.
If you misclassify
Calling a nanny a contractor doesn’t remove the taxes. If you were required to withhold and pay employment taxes and didn’t, you’re generally liable for the taxes you should have withheld and paid, and interest and penalties may be charged. There are separate penalties for late or missing W-2s. Your nanny loses Social Security credit and, in most states, unemployment and disability coverage too.
Next: the hiring checklist walks through setting up as an employer.